Identify
Find argumentative elements such as a claim, evidence, counterclaim, and rebuttal.
Welcome to AdaptEd, an instructional resource hub for adapting learning materials to meet students’ needs. This module demonstrates scaffolded argumentative writing instruction through clear directions, visual models, vocabulary support, sentence frames, and guided practice. These supports can benefit diverse learners, including English Language Learners.
The instruction is designed to help 10th-grade English learners practice one writing skill at a time while working toward the same core learning objectives as their peers.
Find argumentative elements such as a claim, evidence, counterclaim, and rebuttal.
Distinguish the parts of an argument and construct a complete claim supported by evidence.
Use reasoning to explain how different elements support your argument at hand.
This module and platform was developed by Mr. Ryan A. Allen, a high school English Educator and instructional technology design graduate student. His work focuses on making grade level instruction more accessible through purposeful scaffolds while preserving the original learning objective.
Client: High School ESOL Educator and Specialist, Mrs. Maria Lemus. Mrs. Lemus currently supports 9th-12th grade English Language Learners. The module responds to a need for explicit, accessible writing instruction for learners with varied English proficiency and prior schooling experiences.
By working through the module, learners will practice how to:
Complete the five learning modules in order. Each module focuses on one foundational argumentative-writing skill and includes direct access to the existing AdaptEd Student Studio.
Find the claim, evidence, counterclaim, and rebuttal in an argument.
Success check: I can find the parts of an argument in a text.
Tell the difference between a claim, evidence, counterclaim, and rebuttal.
Success check: I can explain what each element does and their purpose.
Write one complete sentence that clearly states a position.
Success check: My claim states what I believe or argue.
Choose evidence from a text that supports the claim.
Success check: My evidence connects to my claim and comes from a reliable source.
Explain in two or three sentences how the evidence proves or supports the claim.
Success check: My reasoning explains the connection instead of merely repeating the evidence.
Complete the baseline writing task without sentence frames, organizers, or visual guides. This will be where you witness your growth once done. Use a student assigned code rather than your name.
Open baseline task ↗Complete the final writing task and reaction survey. Compare the baseline and final responses to consider growth.
Open growth and evaluation area ↗This guide explains how to access the adapted instructional resources and use AdaptEd to collect and review learner progress. The companion website provides directions; the AdaptEd platform is where you use the resources and manage progress information.
Use AdaptEd—not this companion website—to record, review, and retain progress information for your own instructional monitoring.
Platform screens and available data features may change as AdaptEd is developed. Follow the controls currently available in your version.
Open AdaptEd progress and growth area ↗Identify the argumentative-writing skills learners demonstrate, such as recognizing a claim, selecting evidence, or explaining reasoning.
Use the progress information to decide whether to reteach a skill, provide another model, or offer additional vocabulary and sentence support.
Use these steps as you complete the writing module. Work at a steady pace, read the directions, and use the supports that help you explain your ideas.
Before you start the lessons, write a response to the baseline prompt. Try it on your own without the sentence frames or graphic organizers.
Start with IDENTIFY. Then complete DISTINGUISH, CONSTRUCT, SUPPORT, and EXPLAIN. Read each objective and follow the directions on the screen.
You may use the color-coded visual guide, vocabulary word bank, sentence frames, and Claim–Evidence–Reasoning organizer. These tools help you organize your thinking.
Before you submit or move on, ask: Did I answer the question? Did I write a complete sentence? Did I use evidence when asked? Did I explain how the evidence supports my claim?
At the end, complete the final writing task and share feedback about what helped you learn and what could be clearer. Help me, help you!
My position or answer.
Frame: I believe that ___.
Proof from a text or source.
Frame: According to the text, ___.
How the evidence supports your claim.
Frame: This supports my claim because ___.
The other side and your response to it.
Frames: Some people argue ___. However, ___.
Your feedback helps your teacher understand whether the lesson was clear, easy to use, useful, and engaging. Answer honestly. There are no right or wrong answers.
The existing AdaptEd platform includes the reaction survey alongside the baseline task, final task, and growth comparison.
When you finish the modules, open the growth and evaluation area and choose the Reaction Survey tab.
Open AdaptEd reaction survey ↗If the survey tab does not open automatically, use the tab controls on the AdaptEd page to select “Reaction survey.”